Menu

Thanksgiving Pie (Pre-Order)

Start pre-ordering your Thanksgiving Pies now! We have 5 different flavors you can choose from:

Coconut Cream

Chocolate Cream

Pecan

Pumpkin

Apple

Deadline for ordering is November 23rd. No pies will be available in-store. Pre-order only.

Pickup in either Yukon or Edmond.

PICKUP DATE:

Wednesday, November 27th (open 11am to 6pm)

PLEASE NOTE your pie flavor selection in the “Order notes” section at checkout. Be sure to select the 27th for pickup. Thank you.

$24.00

quantity
Category:

Related Products

mini cupcake dozen

12 Pack Mini Cupcakes (Baker’s Choice)

$18.00 $15.00
Our most popular item is the mini dozen. Let us select our favorite 12 flavors for you!
Add to cart
Dozen cupcakes

12 Pack Big Cupcakes (Baker’s Choice)

$42.00 $35.00
Love our cupcakes, but can't decide which flavors? No problem! Let us decide and get a wonderful variety of our best.
Add to cart
avalanche bars

Avalanche Bar

$3.50
Peanut butter, white chocolate, rice cereal and marshmallows. (Gluten-Free)
Add to cart

Keep It Local OK Card 2020

$15.00
ButterSweet is family owned and we are local! Get rewarded for eating, shopping and playing local at over 300 locations across Oklahoma, including 10% off at ButterSweet locations all year long. Please Note: Cards are good for the calendar year, so the 2020 CARD EXPIRES 12/31/20.
Add to cart

WE ARE OPEN!

 

All Bakeries are baking!

All three bakeries are taking online, phone and delivery orders. Lobbies are open for take-out service only. Curbside pickup is available upon request. We always strive for a spotless bakery, but we are taking additional hygiene and sanitation measures in order to protect you and our staff. Thank you for supporting local!